Transforming performance appraisal through appreciative inquiry
Abstract
As an essential organizational process, performance appraisal effectiveness remains an unrealized hope. The research question addressed here is can Appreciative Inquiry (Cooperrider and Whitney, 2000) alter an organization’s performance appraisal narrative? This qualitative field study offers an innovative enhancement to Murphy and Cleveland’s (1995) performance appraisal communication model by incorporating Appreciative Inquiry as a meta-narrative transformative intervention. Results showed that organization members interpret individual performance appraisal experiences in light of the organization’s overall performance meta-narrative. Further, employee interpretations can be positively influenced when they are encouraged to adopt an affirming and hopeful lens that honors performance appraisal’s cultural inheritance. The outcomes are attributed to a few organization members dreaming of the process at its best based on previous positive experiences and then expressing their vision in wider and wider circles of sharing. Although based on a small, convenience sample, this intervention also indicated Appreciative Inquiry may offer unique and helpful advantages in performance appraisal research.Keywords:
Performance Appraisal, Appreciative Inquiry, Human Resources ManagementReferences
ANDERSON, H., K.J. GERGEN, S. MCNAMEE, D. COOPERRIDE, M. GERGEN and D. WHITNEY (2001), “The appreciative organization”, Taos, New Mexico: Taos Institute Publications.
ARVEY, R.D. and K.R. MURPHY (1998), “Performance evaluations in work settings”, Annual Review of Psychology, Vol. 49, pp. 141-68.
BEER, M. (1981), “Performance appraisal: Dilemmas and possibilities”, Organizational Dynamics, (Winter), pp. 24-37.
BERNARDIN, H.J., C.M. HAGAN, J.S. KANE and P. VILLANOVA (1998), “Effective performance management: A focus on precision, customers, and situational constraints”, In J. W. Smither (Ed.), Performance appraisal: State of the art in practice (pp. 3-48), San Francisco: Jossey Bass.
BOSWELL, W.R. and J.W. BOUDREAU (2000), “Employee satisfaction with performance appraisals and appraisers: The role of perceived appraisal use”, Human Resource Development Quarterly, Vol. 11(3), pp. 283-299.
BOWMAN, J.S. (1999), “Performance appraisal: Verisimilitude trumps veracity”, Public Personnel Management, Vol. 28(4), pp. 557-572.
BRETZ, R.D., G.T. MILKOVICH and W. READ (1992), “The current state of performance appraisal research and practice: Concerns, directions and implications”, Journal of Management, Vol. 18(2), pp. 321-352.
BUSHE, G.R. (1999), “Advances in appreciative inquiry as an organization development intervention”, Organization Development Journal, Vol. 17(2), pp. 61-67.
BUSHE, G.R. (2000), “Five theories of change embedded in appreciative inquiry”, in D.L. Cooperrider, P.F. Sorensen, D. Whitney and T. Yaeger (Eds.), Appreciative inquiry: Rethinking human organization toward a positive theory of change (pp. 99-109), Champaign, Illinois: Stipes.
CEDERBLOM, D. (1982), “The performance appraisal interview: A review, implications, and suggestions”, Academy of Management Review, Vol. 7(2), pp. 219-227.
COENS, T. and M. JENKINS (2000), “Abolishing performance appraisals”, San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler.
CONNELLY, F.M. and D.J. CLANDININ (1990), “Stories of experience and narrative inquiry”, Educational Researcher, Vol. 19(5), pp. 2-14.
COOPERRIDER, D.L. and S. SRIVASTVA, (2000), “Appreciative inquiry in organizational life”, in D.L. Cooperrider, P.F. Sorensen, D. Whitney and T. Yaeger (Eds.), Appreciative inquiry: Rethinking human organization toward a positive theory of change, (pp. 55-97), Champaign, Illinois: Stipes.
COOPERRIDER, D.L. and D. WHITNEY (2000), “A positive revolution in change: Appreciative inquiry”, in D.L. Cooperrider, P.F. Sorensen, D. Whitney and T. Yaeger (Eds.), Appreciative inquiry: Rethinking human organization toward a positive theory of change, (pp. 3-27), Champaign, Illinois: Stipes.
DUNLAP, C.A. (2008), “Effective evaluation through appreciative inquiry”, Performance Improvement, Vol. 47(2), pp. 23-29.
FLETCHER, C. (2001), “Performance appraisal and management: The developing research agenda”, Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, Vol. 74, pp. 473-487.
GERGEN, M.M., K.J. GERGEN and F. BARRETT (2004), “Appreciative inquiry as dialogue: Generative and transformative”, in D.L. Cooperrider and M. Avital (Eds.), Constructive discourse and human organization, (pp. 3-27). Amsterdam: Elsevier.
GOLEMBIEWSKI, R.T. (1999), “Fine-tuning appreciative inquiry: Two ways of circumscribing the concept’s value-added”, Organization Development Journal, Vol. 17(3), pp. 21-27.
HALACHMI, A. (1993); “From performance appraisal to performance targeting”, Public Personnel Management, Vol. 22(2), pp 323-344.
ILGEN, D.R., C.D. FISHER and M.S. TAYLOR (1979), “Consequences of individual feedback on behavior in organizations”, Journal of Applied Psychology, Vol. 4, pp. 349-371.
LAWLER, E.E., A.M. MOHRMAN and S.M. RESNICK (1984), “Performance appraisal revisited”, Organizational Dynamics, Vol. 13, pp. 20-35.
LONGENECKER, C.O. (1997), “Why managerial performance appraisals are ineffective: Causes and lessons”, Career Development International, Vol. 2(5), pp. 212-218.
LONGENECKER, C.O. and S.J. GOFF (1992), “Performance appraisal effectiveness: A matter of perspective”, SAM Advanced Management Journal (Spring), pp. 17-23.
LUDEMA, J.D. (2000), “From deficit discourse to vocabularies of hope: The power of appreciation”, in D. L. Cooperrider, P.F. Sorensen, D. Whitney and T. Yaeger (Eds.), Appreciative inquiry: Rethinking human organization toward a positive theory of change (pp. 265-287), Champaign, Illinois: Stipes.
MOUNT, K.M. (1984), “Satisfaction with a performance appraisal system and appraisal discussion”, Journal of Occupational Behavior, Vol. 5, pp. 271-279.
MURPHY, K.R. and J.N. CLEVELAND (1995), “Understanding performance appraisal: Social, organizational, and goal-based perspectives”, Thousand Oaks, California: Sage.
MYERS, D.W., W.R. JOHNSTON and C.G. Pearce (1991), “The role of human interaction theory in developing models of performance appraisal feedback”, SAM Advanced Management Journal, pp. 28-33.
NORUM, K.E., M. WELLS, M.R. HOADLEY, C.A GEARY and R. THOMPSON (2004), “Ap-praisal-al: An appreciative approach to program evaluation”, Constructive discourse in human organizations, pp. 193-214, Amsterdam: Elsevier.
OLSEN, L.O. and A.D. BENNETT (1975, December), “Performance appraisal: Management technique or social process?” (Part 1), Management Review, pp. 18-23.
OLSEN, L.O. and A.D. BENNET (1976, January), “Performance appraisal: Management technique or social process?” (Part 2), Management Review, pp. 22-28.
RIESSMAN, C.K. (1993), “Narrative analysis”, Newbury Park, California: Sage.
SRIVASTVA, S., R.E. FRY and D.L. COOPERRIDER (1999), “Introduction: The call for executive appreciation”, in S. Srivastva and D.L. Cooperrider (Eds.), Appreciative Management and Leadership. Euclid, OH: Williams Custom Publishing
THOMAS, S.L. and R.D. BRETZ (1994), “Research and practice in performance appraisal: Evaluating employee performance in America’s largest companies”, SAM Advanced Management Journal, Vol. 4, pp. 28-34.
WANGURI, D.M. (1995), “A review, an integration and a critique of cross-disciplinary research on performance appraisals, evaluations and feedback: 1980-1990”, The Journal of Business Communication, Vol. 32(3), pp. 267-293.
WHEATLEY, M. J. (2005). “Finding our way”, San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler.
WHEATLEY, M.J. and M. Kellner-Rogers (1996), “A simpler way”, San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler.
WHITNEY, D. (1998), “Let’s change the subject t and change our organization: An appreciative inquiry approach to organization change”, Career Development International, Vol. 3(7), pp. 314-319.
WHITNEY, D. and A. TROSTEN-BLOOM (2003), “The power of appreciative inquiry: A practical guide to positive change”, San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler.
WHITNEY, D., and C, SCHAU (1998), “Appreciative inquiry: An innovative process for organization change”, Employment Relations Today, (Spring), pp. 11-21.
WIESE, D. and M.R. BUCKLEY (1998), “The evolution of the performance appraisal process”, Journal of Management History, Vol. 4(3), pp. 233-249.
